Turmeric Syntax Guide

This guide is the front door to Turmeric's surface syntax. It teaches you to read and write Turmeric source in both dialects:

  1. The default S-expression dialect used by .tur files. SRFI-105 curly-infix is enabled here too -- {a + b} reads as (+ a b) in every dialect, no #lang directive required.
  2. The sweet-expression dialect activated by #lang turmeric/sweet (legacy alias: #lang sweet-exp) or a .tur.sweet extension (indentation + neoteric + $ + curly-infix).

The #lang line names one base dialect and nothing else; see Part 2.5.

It does not re-explain the semantics of every special form -- the deep-dive guides own that. Instead it shows you the shape of the language and points you at the right reference for the details.

Throughout, code is shown in paired blocks: a turmeric block followed by its sweet-exp equivalent. Use the toggle above each pair to switch between them.


Part 1 -- S-expression syntax

The default dialect is a Lisp. Every program is a tree of forms: atoms (numbers, strings, symbols, keywords) and lists that group them.

Lexical conventions

Identifiers are symbols like square, vec-push!, option-some?, or make-adder. Conventionally, a trailing ! marks mutation (vec-push!) and a trailing ? marks a predicate (option-none?). Operators like +, -, *, <=, and = are ordinary identifiers used in prefix position.

Keywords start with a colon: :int, :as, :name. They are self-evaluating and most often appear as type annotations, option names, and map keys.

Numbers include integers (42, -5), floats (3.14, 0.1), and the radix forms documented in the reader reference -- hex (0xFF), binary (0b1010), and octal (0o755).

Strings are double-quoted with C-style escapes ("line\n", "tab\tend", "quote\"inside").

ASCII only. Source must be ASCII -- the reader hangs on non-ASCII bytes such as UTF-8 em dashes. Always write -- (double hyphen), never an em dash.

For the exhaustive catalogue of literal forms (radix integers, character escapes, keyword rules), see the Reader Forms Reference.

Comments

(println "hi")  ; line comment -- to end of line

#|
  Block comment. These nest:
  #| inner |#
|#
(println "ok")

Doc comments use the triple-semicolon marker ;;; and sit immediately above a defn, defmacro, defstruct, or definstance. The docstring format (its required Parameters:/Returns:/Example:/Since: sections) is specified in the project's docstring standard. See the Reader Forms Reference for the full comment catalogue including the planned datum comment #;.

The form tree

Turmeric has four bracketed containers, each legal in specific positions:

Form Syntax Where it is legal
List (f x y) everywhere -- the universal form
Vector [a b c] binding position (let/defn params); expression position
Map literal #map{:k v} expression position
Set literal #set{a b} expression position

In binding position [...] is a binding spec (parameter list or let bindings). In expression position, [...] lowers to (vec-of ...). See the Data Literals Guide for the literal collection semantics.

Function application

A list evaluates as a call: the head is the function, the rest are arguments. Zero-argument calls are just an empty-argument list.

(+ 1 2)            ; => 3
(square 9)         ; => 81
(vec-new)          ; zero-arg call

Threading a value through calls: -> and ->>

(-> x step ...) passes a value through a chain of calls as each one's first argument; ->> passes it as each one's last argument. A bare name as a step is called with the value alone. They read top to bottom where nested calls read inside out (tur/forms/control):

(defn add [a : int b : int] : int (+ a b))
(defn double [x : int] : int (* 2 x))

(defn main [] : int
  (println (-> 5 (add 1) double))        ; (double (add 5 1)) => 12
  (println (->> 5 (- 100) double))       ; (double (- 100 5))  => 190
  0)

(-> x) is just x. The builder style in cli-args-guide ((-> (args/spec-new) (args/flag ...) ...)) is -> over functions that take the spec first and return it.

Special forms you will see first

These are the forms a newcomer meets immediately. This guide only shows their shape; follow the links for semantics.

def and defn -- bind a value or a function. Parameter and return types are annotated with :type:

(defn square [x : int] : int (* x x))

(square 9)    ; => 81

let -- local bindings scoped to its body:

(let [x 10 y 20] (+ x y))   ; => 30

if -- an expression; both branches required:

(defn abs [n : int] : int
  (if (< n 0) (- 0 n) n))

cond -- ordered multi-way branch with an else fallback:

(defn sign [n : int] : int
  (cond (> n 0) 1
        (< n 0) -1
        else    0))

The fallback clause is also spelled :else -- the keyword is the older spelling and still accepted, in cond and in case alike, so the two may be mixed within one file.

else is not a global binding: outside a clause head it is still an unbound symbol, so (if else 1 2) remains an error. The one program the bare spelling changes is an exotic one -- a cond whose test position reads a variable named else. Rename that variable; the clause head now wins.

when -- one-armed conditional for side effects:

(when (< x 0) (println "negative"))

fn -- an anonymous function capturing its lexical scope:

(let [add5 (fn [x : int] : int (+ x 5))]
  (add5 10))    ; => 15

for -- bind a counter over a half-open range:

(for i 0 5 (println i))

Other forms you will meet -- do (sequence side effects), while (loop while a condition holds), import/export (module wiring), defstruct (record types), and defmacro (syntax extension). Each has a dedicated guide:

A while may carry a written loop invariant directly after its condition -- (while (< i n) :invariant (>= i 0) body...) -- which is checked on entry and after every iteration and, when proved, usable after the loop (see refinement-types-guide.md).

Type-annotation syntax

Types appear after a name with a leading colon. In a parameter list each parameter is followed by its type; the return type follows the closing ] of the parameter vector:

(defn add [a : int b : int] : int (+ a b))

Compound types use parenthesised constructors -- (vec T), (-> a b), forall, and friends. A variadic tail is written & rest :T. The full compound-annotation grammar is in the Type Annotations Guide; variadic rules are in the function-arity section of the project conventions.

Naming a type -- defalias vs deftype

Two forms bind a type name, and they do different things.

defalias is the transparent alias. The name and its target are the same type everywhere, so the alias never shows up in unification -- it is a readability tool, not a new type. The target can be any type expression:

(defalias Sample    :int)                            ; primitive
(defalias IntList   (Cons int))                      ; type application
(defalias Point     P)                               ; struct / ADT name
(defalias Backtrack (fn [] int))                     ; function type
(defalias NonZero   #refine{ q : int | (not= q 0) }) ; refinement

Because it is transparent, (defn f [b : Backtrack] : int (b)) applies b exactly as (fn [] int) would, and a Point is accepted anywhere a P is.

deftype is the recursive type binder. It wraps its body in a recursive type, which is what Fix/Free need, and takes its parameters as a bracket vector:

(deftype Fix [^f] (f (Fix f)))

That wrapping makes deftype the wrong tool for naming a non-recursive type: the bound name is a distinct nominal type, so use sites fail to unify with the body. Reach for defalias there. The one exception is a bare refinement body, which deftype binds transparently for stdlib/refine.tur's benefit -- defalias handles that case too, and is the clearer spelling in new code.

Neither form takes alias type parameters: (defalias Name [a] ...) is an error, and a deftype's parameters belong to the recursive type, not to an alias. For a named parametric shape, use defstruct/defdata.

Two more forms are adjacent but distinct: defopaque makes a nominal newtype (deliberately not interchangeable with its representation), and defstruct declares a record.

Indentation conventions

Turmeric source follows Clojure-style indentation.

Regular calls align arguments under the first argument:

(some-long-fn arg1
              arg2
              arg3)

Special forms and macros (defn, fn, let, if, when, do, cond, for, while) use a fixed 2-space body indent regardless of column:

(defn greet [name :cstr] :void
  (println name))

Binding vectors align pairs under one another, one pair per line. Never split a name from its value across lines:

(let [x   1
      y   2
      foo (+ x y)]
  foo)

The canonical formatter enforces these rules automatically -- see Canonical formatting below.

Inline-C blocks

Turmeric can embed C in a fenced ```c ... ``` block inside a defn body. The closing triple-backtick must share its line with the enclosing ) -- written ```) -- so that Markdown renderers do not mistake it for the end of a surrounding documentation code fence:

(defn file-size [f] :int
  ```c
  FILE* file = (FILE*)f;
  return (int)ftell(file);
  ```)

See the C Integration Guide for FFI details and the Reader Forms Reference for the fence grammar.


Part 2 -- Sweet-expression syntax

Sweet-expressions are an alternate surface syntax that removes most parentheses without changing the underlying form tree. Every sweet-exp program reads to the same AST as its s-expression equivalent -- the toggle widgets in this guide are verified to be parse-equal.

Opting in

Activate sweet-exp one of two ways:

A complete runnable snippet opens with the directive:

(defn main [] :int 0)

Inline fragments in prose omit the directive (as the paired examples in this guide do). If the directive is absent and the file is not .tur.sweet, the reader stays in plain s-expression mode and treats indentation as insignificant.

Both activations work the same way whether the file is the one you compile or one pulled in by (load "..."): a loaded file's dialect is read from its own first line and its own extension, independently of whatever dialect the loading file is written in. When both are present the extension picks the base dialect and the directive is a redundant hint.

The three tools

Sweet-exp gives you three independent tools. Use whichever reduces noise for a given expression; they compose freely.

1. Indentation (t-expr) -- a leading-whitespace block replaces the outer (...) of a form. Use it for top-level forms and multi-line bodies:

(defn factorial [n : int] : int
  (if (<= n 1) 1 (* n (factorial (- n 1)))))

2. Neoteric f(x y) -- replaces (f x y) for inline calls. The opening paren must touch the function name with no space. Operators work too -- +(x y) is (+ x y):

(println (vec-len v))

3. Rest-of-line $ -- replaces the outer (...) when a line's only argument is itself a single nested call. Prefer it over neoteric when the outer call takes exactly one argument:

(println (vec-get squares i))

$ wraps everything to its right in one pair of parens -- but only when the rest of the line is a bare token sequence that needs the wrap. When the rest is already one complete delimited expression -- a neoteric call, a parenthesised form, a curly-infix group, a data literal -- the wrap is suppressed, so $ composes with the other two tools instead of double-applying them:

Rest-of-line shape Written Reads as
bare token sequence println $ vec-get squares i (println (vec-get squares i))
neoteric call println $ vec-get(squares i) (println (vec-get squares i))
parenthesised form println $ (vec-get squares i) (println (vec-get squares i))
curly-infix group println $ {a + b} (println (+ a b))
chained $ println $ normalize $ vec3(x y z) (println (normalize (vec3 x y z)))

A bare atom after $ is still wrapped, per SRFI-110 -- f $ g reads as (f (g)), a zero-argument call, not (f g). Pass a function value with plain juxtaposition (f(g) or (f g)) rather than $.

Curly-infix {a op b}

Arithmetic and comparison read more naturally in infix. {a + b} lowers to (+ a b); nesting makes precedence visual:

(let [hyp (sqrt (+ (* a a) (* b b)))] hyp)

Data literals inside sweet-exp

The #map{...}, #set{...}, and [...] literals work transparently inside sweet-exp -- the reader dispatch sits below the sweet-exp layer, so neoteric and curly-infix compose inside a literal. See the Data Literals Guide for the full semantics.

What still uses traditional parens

A few forms stay clearer in s-expression syntax even in a sweet-exp file:

fn -- keep the parens

A lambda is almost always an argument to something else, so the sweet forms bury the one delimiter that tells you where the lambda ends. Neoteric fn( in particular reads as a call to a function named fn:

; Hard to scan -- where does the lambda stop?
over(px fn([v : int] : int {v * 10}) p)

; Clear -- the lambda is visibly one argument of three
over(px (fn [v : int] : int {v * 10}) p)

Curly-infix and neoteric still apply inside the body. Only the fn head keeps its parens.

One consequence is worth stating outright, because it bites: a (...) form switches the indentation layer off for everything inside it -- indentation and $. Only delimiter-based syntax survives: s-expression calls, neoteric calls f(x), and curly-infix {a + b}. Once a lambda is parenthesised, its body must be delimiter-complete:

; BROKEN -- `when` was relying on indentation the parens just took away, so
; this parses as four flat elements: fn, [], when, {..}, perform(..)
(fn []
  when {read-tvar(x) < 10}
    perform(Retry()))

; Correct
(fn []
  (when {read-tvar(x) < 10}
    perform(Retry())))

$ is caught for you. A $ inside brackets is rejected with TUR-E0332, pointing at the marker:

; TUR-E0332: `$` has no meaning inside brackets
(fn [msg : cstr] : unit
  log/error $ str("a" msg))

; Correct -- give the call a delimiter
(fn [msg : cstr] : unit
  log/error(str("a" msg)))

tur explain TUR-E0332 has the long form. The same $ is correct as soon as it is outside every bracket, where the indentation layer is live again:

defn f [msg : cstr] : nil
  log/error $ str("a" msg)      ; (log/error (str "a" msg))

handle -- keep the clause and its body on one line

handle takes a flat argument list that pairs up two at a time: (handle expr (Eff [p] k) body (Eff2 [p] k) body ...). Sweet-exp indentation gives every element its own line, which splits each clause from the body that answers it -- so the pairing, the only thing a reader needs, is exactly what the layout destroys:

; Bad -- which body belongs to which clause? Count lines and hope.
println
  handle compute()
    (Add [x] k)
    resume(k {x + 10})
    (Mul [x] k)
    resume(k {x * 2})

Write handle in traditional parens, one clause per line:

; Good -- the pairing is on the page
println
  (handle (compute)
    (Add [x] k) (resume k {x + 10})   ; 3+10 = 13
    (Mul [x] k) (resume k {x * 2}))   ; 4*2  =  8

When a clause body shares the line with its clause, write it in s-expression form. Curly-infix {a + b} stays; it is more readable for arithmetic and is legal in every dialect. Mixing neoteric into a packed one-liner makes it a two- or three-syntax hybrid that scans worse than either pure form:

; Bad -- neoteric, s-expr and a neoteric zero-arg call on one line
(Log [msg] k) (do println(msg) (resume k nil-value()))

; Good
(Log [msg] k) (do (println msg) (resume k (nil-value)))

A multi-line body under a ;; comment is ordinary code -- neoteric and curly-infix read fine there, exactly as in a (fn ...) body. The one-liner rule is about line density, not about banning neoteric inside handle:

(handle
  (let [new-state update-state(state)]
    draw(new-state)
    game-loop(new-state))
  ;; Render is forwarded to the backend, then the loop continues.
  (Render [obj] k)
    (do handle-render(obj)
        (resume k)))

match has the same flat pair-up-two-at-a-time shape as handle, so it takes the same treatment: one pattern per line with the body it answers.

When a body is too long to share the line, give the clause its own ;; comment and indent the body under it -- punctuate the block rather than letting the clauses run together:

(handle (serve req)
  ;; Log, then continue with the untouched request.
  (Log [msg] k)
    (do (println msg)
        (resume k nil))
  ;; A missing session is not fatal -- resume with the anonymous user.
  (Session [] k)
    (resume k (anonymous-user)))

Mixing styles

You can mix s-expressions and sweet-exp tools within one sweet-exp file -- the two share a form tree, so a traditional (...) list is always legal inside an indented block, and neoteric/$/curly-infix may appear anywhere an expression is expected. The guidance above (when to fall back to parens) is a style recommendation, not a parser restriction. The canonical formatter normalises plain .tur files but does not rewrite a sweet-exp file into s-expressions or vice versa -- the dialect is a property of the source you choose to write.

Side-by-side: a complete function

Here is make-adder -- a function returning a closure -- shown in both dialects. (Lifted from the quickstart so it stays honest.)

(defn make-adder [n : int] (fn [x : int] : int (+ x n)))

(let [add3 (make-adder 3)
      add7 (make-adder 7)]
  (println (add3 10))    ; 13
  (println (add7 10)))   ; 17

Part 2.5 -- #lang base dialects

A #lang line selects one base dialect. Its full shape is:

#lang <language>[/<reader>]

and nothing else on the line. It is read before the first form, so the choice is declared up front and is guaranteed file-scoped. It must be the first line: the detector skips spaces and tabs before it, but not comments, so a comment above the directive silently disables it.

tur dialects lists the bases, and tur dialects --json emits the same thing machine-readably.

A base names a language and a reader

The first, possibly slash-namespaced, token names two things: which language the forms are elaborated as, and which reader parses them. For turmeric and saffron they are independent axes, so each is spellable over every reader; r7rs brings its own reader and takes no slash.

Base Language Reader
turmeric turmeric plain s-expression (the default; curly-infix is always on)
turmeric/curly-infix turmeric curly-infix emphasis (same as the default)
turmeric/neoteric turmeric curly-infix + neoteric f(x)
turmeric/sweet turmeric full sweet-expressions (indentation + neoteric + $)
saffron saffron plain s-expression
saffron/curly-infix saffron curly-infix emphasis
saffron/neoteric saffron curly-infix + neoteric
saffron/sweet saffron full sweet-expressions
r7rs r7rs the Scheme reader (#t/#f, #\c, #(...), ,/,@, dotted pairs, |sym|, #x/#e... prefixes)

Saffron is the dynamically typed dialect: an unannotated parameter or return defaults to any instead of int, and the file gets a dynamic operator layer, dynamic calls and dynamic field access. Annotations stay legal, and a Saffron module links against a Turmeric one in the same program. See the Saffron guide.

R7RS is R7RS-small Scheme, over Saffron's dynamic substrate under a Scheme reader (r7rs-lang-plan.md). It graduated in v0.57.0: tur dialects shows it as stable, tur experiments no longer lists a row, the #lang r7rs line is all that is needed, and no lifecycle warning is printed. Today it has the reader (R1), the core forms (R2): define, lambda, the let family, do, cond/case, and/or, set!, case-lambda, multiple values and the core list, equality and output procedures, with Scheme truthiness (only #f is false); and the data and the seam (R3): mutable pairs, chars, vectors, bytevectors, records, quote/quasiquote as data, equal? on cycles, define-library, and import with only/prefix/rename and the (turmeric <module>) head, so a Scheme program calls a Turmeric module or the stdlib and a Turmeric module imports a define-library (its exports are any, narrowed with cast). Strings are character sequences; a literal is an immutable cstr and a string a procedure makes is mutable (T3). R4 adds syntax-rules -- define-syntax, let-syntax, letrec-syntax, syntax-error, the full pattern language and renaming hygiene (a template's own binders cannot capture a use-site name; R10 closes the other direction, so a template's free identifiers mean what they meant where the macro was defined). R5 adds the numbers: exact integers are int64 and continue as bignums past it (T1), inexact reals are doubles, (/ 7 2) is the exact ratio 7/2 (T2), 3+4i is a complex number and (sqrt -4) is +2i (T6), and the R7RS predicate, rounding, division, expt/sqrt/transcendental and radix number->string/string->number surface is there. R6 adds control: call/cc (re-entrant since T5: a continuation can be invoked after its call/cc has returned, any number of times, which re-runs dynamic-wind before thunks), dynamic-wind, with-exception-handler/raise/raise-continuable/guard and error objects (an uncaught raise reports on stderr and exits 70), parameterize/make-parameter, and delay/delay-force/force. Every Scheme procedure call is a proper tail call on both back ends, and the compiled back end runs everything the interpreter does (a dynamic call is capped at four arguments, so apply is too). R7 completes the libraries short of ports: the rest of (scheme base), and (scheme char) (ASCII case mapping), (scheme cxr), (scheme complex), (scheme time), (scheme process-context) and (scheme file)'s file-exists? and delete-file. The last three are loaded only when imported. include is refused with the reason. (scheme eval), (scheme repl), (scheme load) and (scheme r5rs) give eval, environment, interaction-environment, null-environment, scheme-report-environment and load (T4). Importing one links the interpreter into a compiled program, and a program that imports none links nothing extra. Evaluated code runs in one embedded R7RS session per run: data crosses by copy, and procedures and raised objects cross in both directions. R8 adds ports: string, bytevector and file ports, read-char/read-line/ read-string/read-u8 and the rest of the R7RS I/O procedures, the current ports as parameters ((parameterize ((current-output-port p)) ...)), write/display that label cycles (#0=(1 2 . #0#)), write-shared and write-simple, (scheme read), and (scheme file)'s open-input-file, call-with-output-file, with-output-to-file and the rest. One caution for the compiled back end: a top-level define whose initializer has an effect (opening a file, reading input) runs before the program's top-level expressions, so put such code inside a procedure. R9 adds the tooling: tur repl --lang r7rs, tur fmt (which re-indents a Scheme file and never rewrites a token), tur init --r7rs, the language server, and editor highlighting. R10 runs chibi-scheme's R7RS test suite as a ctest target (tur_r7rs_conformance) that reports a pass count: 1082 of the 1216 tests written in it pass, on both back ends, and the rest are the named carve-outs (bignums, exact rationals, complex numbers, mutable strings, eval, re-entrant call/cc); Section 9's tasks have since closed all of them, for 1223 passing invocations and none failing (two tests of chibi's own float spelling, e+308, are counted as settled: R7RS allows both). A compiled single-unit Scheme program allocates through the conservative collector on Linux and macOS (TUR_R7RS_GC=0 or --no-r7rs-gc opts out, which a program that starts threads must do), and every Scheme fixture runs under ASan and UBSan in tur_r7rs_sanitize (T8). (scheme char) maps and classifies all of Unicode, from tables generated out of the Unicode database. The full reference is r7rs-guide.md.

turmeric, saffron and r7rs are all stable bases -- none is gated. #lang saffron and #lang r7rs each need no --enable= flag and no :experiments entry, and print no lifecycle warning; tur dialects lists all ten bases as stable.

turmeric/sweet is the preferred spelling for the sweet-exp base. The older #lang sweet-exp is still accepted as a legacy alias, so #lang sweet-exp and #lang turmeric/sweet are equivalent -- migrate to the slash-namespaced form when convenient. A .tur.sweet extension selects the sweet base without any directive.

Bases do not compose (sweet-exp is a whole indentation pass; curly/neoteric are flags on the same reader), which is exactly why they share the one slash-named slot.

Nothing follows the base

A token after the base name is a compile error (TUR-E0330), never silently ignored:

error [TUR-E0330]: `#lang` takes a single base dialect; unexpected trailing
token 'boguslayer' in path/to/file.tur

There used to be a second axis here -- an additive, order-independent set of layers after the base, each flipping on a #-dispatch or an elaboration gate. It was decommissioned. Its two members are both better served elsewhere, and that is the rule to follow when you want one:

Migration. stringed -- the only layer token that ever shipped -- is still accepted for one minor line, warned once (TUR-W0064) and ignored, so a file that opted in per-file keeps compiling across the boundary. Drop the token; nothing is lost, because what it turned on is now always on. At 0.50.0 it becomes the same TUR-E0330 any other trailing token gets. See the decommission plan.


Part 3 -- Reference appendix

Form cheat sheet

One row per construct: the s-expr form, its sweet-exp form, and a one-line gloss.

Construct S-expression Sweet-expression Gloss
Call (f x y) f(x y) function application
Operator (+ x y) {x + y} or +(x y) infix arithmetic / prefix op
One-arg call (f (g x)) f $ g(x) rest-of-line argument
Define fn (defn f [x :int] :int ...) defn f [x :int] :int + indent named function
Anon fn (fn [x :int] :int ...) fn([x :int] :int ...) closure
Local binding (let [x 1] ...) let [x 1] + indent scoped names
Conditional (if c a b) if c + indent two-armed expression
Multi-branch (cond p1 e1 else e) cond + indented pairs ordered dispatch
Side-effect guard (when c ...) when c + indent one-armed conditional
Counted loop (for i 0 n ...) for i 0 n ... range iteration
Sequence (do a b) do + indent evaluate in order
Vector literal [a b c] [a b c] growable array
Map literal #map{:k v} #map{:k v} HAMT map
Set literal #set{a b} #set{a b} set

Where to go deeper

Topic In-depth guide
Every reader form / literal grammar reader-forms-guide.md
Data literal semantics data-literals-guide.md
Local binding forms binding-forms-guide.md
Compound type annotations type-annotations-guide.md
Structs structs-guide.md
Modules / import / export module-system-guide.md
C interop / inline-C c-integration-guide.md
Canonical formatting formatter-guide.md
End-to-end prose tour quickstart.md

Canonical formatting

tur format rewrites a file into canonical layout -- applying the indentation rules above so you never have to hand-align. Use --check in CI to fail on drift:

tur format myfile.tur          # rewrite in place (via redirect)
tur format --check myfile.tur  # exit non-zero if not canonical

A before/after gives the flavour -- ragged input on the left, canonical output on the right:

;; before
(defn add [a :int b :int] :int
    (+ a
  b))

;; after `tur format`
(defn add [a :int b :int] :int
  (+ a b))

See the Formatter Guide for the complete rule set and editor integration.

Common mistakes

A short list of pitfalls newcomers hit:

  1. Inline-C fence on its own line. The closing ``` must share a line with ) (written ```)); a lone ``` breaks Markdown rendering.
  2. Splitting a binding pair across lines. Keep each name value (or name :type value) on one line in a let/loop vector.
  3. A space before a neoteric paren. f (x) is not neoteric application -- it reads as f followed by (x). Write f(x).
  4. Non-ASCII bytes. An em dash or smart quote pasted from a doc will hang the reader. Use -- and straight quotes only.
  5. Expecting #lang sweet-exp to enable neoteric in a plain file. Without the directive (or a .tur.sweet extension) the reader stays in s-expression mode and indentation is insignificant.
  6. Mixing up [...] positions. [...] is a value (lowers to vec-of) in expression position and a binding spec (parameter list / let bindings) in binding position -- the context determines which.
  7. Naming a definition after a special form. (defn return ...), (defn match ...), (defmacro open ...) are accepted, but a bare call site dispatches to the form, never to your definition. See Reserved names below -- the compiler flags this as TUR-W0042 at the definition.
  8. An expression at defmodule top level. There is no module-level side-effect position; see What may appear inside a defmodule.
  9. A definition as the last form of a function body. Legal anywhere else in the body, but not last -- see Definitions inside a function body.

Definitions inside a function body

A defn (or any def* form) may appear inside a function body. It is lifted to file scope and stays callable by name from the enclosing function:

(defn outer [] : int
  (defn inner [x : int] : int (+ x 1))
  (inner 5))                  ; => 6

A nested defn may call itself and the nested defns beside it, in either order: all the defns in a body are declared before any of their bodies is checked. A defstruct or defdata there is lifted the same way, so its type and constructors are visible from that point on.

It may not be the last form, unless the function owes no value. A definition produces nothing, so a function declared : int whose body ends with one has nothing to return -- that is TUR-E0713:

(defn outer [] : int
  (let [x (helper)] x)
  (defn other [] : int 7))    ; error [TUR-E0713]

In practice this is almost always a missing close paren: outer was meant to end after x, and everything following it got swallowed into its body. An editor will happily reindent around the slip, so the diagnostic names it. Until 2026-08-29 this was silent -- the function returned 0, which is a successful exit status, a false, and a "nothing found" all at once.

A : nil / : void function may end with a definition, since it owes no value.

What may appear inside a defmodule

A (defmodule ...) body is a list of definitions, not statements. A non-definition form as a direct child is rejected with TUR-E0711:

(defmodule dt
  (defn shout [] : int (println "hi") 1)
  (shout)                     ; error [TUR-E0711] -- never evaluated
  (defn main [] : int 0))

There is no module-level side-effect position, so put the call in main (or a function main calls). This was silent until 2026-08-29: the form was fully elaborated -- type errors inside it reported like live code -- and then dropped from codegen, which cost 12 spices their entire test suites without a single warning.

Legal as a direct child:

Form Note
defn defmacro defmacro*
defstruct defdata defopaque deftype defalias
defclass definstance defeffect
def a module-level global; its initializer does run
extern-c
import export export-from must come first, before any definition
a bare ```c block supplies file-scope C declarations
defer runs at process exit, not at module load

The last two look like expressions and are deliberate. defer is the only non-definition form that executes.

The rule is applied to the form after macro expansion, so a macro that expands to a definition is fine wherever the definition would be:

(defmacro make-adder [name n]
  `(defn ,name [x : int] : int (+ x ,n)))

(make-adder add5 5)           ; OK -- expands to a defn

Reserved names

A call head is matched against the special forms by name, before any binding, macro, or typeclass-method lookup. Naming a defn or defmacro after one of them is accepted and the binding is created, but every bare (name ...) call site elaborates as the form, so the definition is unreachable by its bare name. The compiler emits TUR-W0042 at the definition; run tur explain TUR-W0042 for the full write-up.

return is the one that bites most often -- it is the conventional name for a monadic unit, and (return x) is always the early-return form. Use pure.

Reserved in call-head position:

Group Names
Binding / control def define let let* letrec if do unsafe set! while case defer return match quote gensym ? -> ->>
Definition forms defn fn (and its Greek-letter lambda alias) extern-c defmacro defmodule import export load defstruct make-struct defopaque defdata defgadt (deprecated: defdata with : Result constructors) defclass definstance defkind defrec deftype defalias defdynamic defeffect defprotocol
Generators gen yield gen-next gen-done?
References / rc / weak ref deref drop! ref? weak weak? upgrade lref/new rc/of rc/clone rc/drop rc->ptr rc/strong-count rc/from-ref ref/from-rc
Continuations reset shift shift0 call/cc call/cc* escape cloneable-reset cloneable-shift serial-reset serial-shift cont?
Effects binding perform handle handle-shallow try-with with-handler resume discontinue compose-handlers
Types / casts as type-of cast is? coerce & &mut forall exists type-app (removed: an error naming the applied type (F A); reserved for one more release) :: pack open
Sessions make-protocol make-session
Panic panic panic-with catch-unwind catch-panic-of panic-payload-type panic-payload-value panic-payload-file panic-payload-line panic-payload-downcast
Unsafe / FFI ptr-deref ptr-write ptr-add ptr-sub ptr-null? ptr-of unsafe-cast reinterpret transmute array-get-unchecked array-set-unchecked raw-malloc raw-free raw-realloc raw-memcpy raw-memset c-call dlopen dlsym dlclose
STM / GC stm retry gc! gc-enable! gc-disable! gc-auto! gc-collections gc-objects-freed gc-live-blocks gc-candidate-high-water

A leading . is reserved too: (.method obj ...) is method-call syntax, so a definition named .foo is never reachable as a call head.

Not reserved -- these are deliberately shadowable. A user definition of handler, with, default-of, or a session op (send recv close offer send-to recv-from choose-left choose-right recv-timeout) wins over the form, and the map surface (map-new assoc dissoc get has? count merge) falls back to ordinary call resolution. The arity-gated forms (async await select atomically check or-else thread-spawn and the tvar-* ops) intercept only one call shape, so a definition at a different arity is genuinely callable -- no warning is emitted for those, and the shadowing is worth avoiding anyway.

Inside a defmodule, a shadowing definition remains reachable through its qualified name (mymod/return) -- a qualified head symbol never matches a special form -- but the bare name stays shadowed, so renaming is still better.